Guide to LiPo Batteries Guide to Electric Power Systems Ni-Cad Guide NiMh Guide Lead Acid Guide
 

Gibbs Guides

<<<  Back
 

Get more articles like this one absolutely free with every
Gibbs Guides e-magazine. Join the mailing list!

How to avoid crashing

Part 1 - Building for Survival: The Airframe

Article by Andrew Gibbs

RC electric model crash

Crashing is clearly one of the less appealing experiences of being an aeromodeller. But are crashes an inevitability? Some modellers seem to fly their models for years with few if any mishaps, while others seem to have much worse luck.

The good news is that when we examine what causes crashes, it turns out that it's a lot less to do with luck than we might think. There's actually a lot we can do the minimise the chance of a crash. The chance of a model crashing is directly related to (i) how well it’s built; (ii) how well it’s flown and (iii) on the quality of the maintenance and repairs it receives. A model must receive adequate attention in each of these three areas if it is to have a good chance of long life span.

This first part of this article concentrates on building of the model. Model aircraft are relatively complex machines. There are generally no unnecessary parts, so every part of the machine needs to function properly for the model to be fully airworthy. The components of any electric powered model may be divided into three basic categories;

1. The Airframe
2. The Power System
3. The Control system

Let's look at each of these parts in turn, and discuss what factors can help us avoid the dreaded crash.

 


RC electric model HP 42

2. For a long life span, a model must be well built, well flown and well maintained. This large and beautiful HP42 is the work of Martin Hardy (click image to return to original size).

For a long life span, a model must be well built, well flown and well maintained (click small images to enlarge and get more information).


electric RC Mosquito model airplane tail surfaces

3. Hinges must be securely attached so that there is no danger of separation in flight. This tail belongs to a ARF DH Mosquito (click image to return to original size).

Hinges must be securely attached so that there is no danger of separation (click small images to enlarge and get more information).

 

The Airframe
The term ‘airframe’ refers to those parts making up the structure of the aeroplane; wings, fuselage, tail, control surfaces and the landing gear or undercarriage.

Clearly all models need to be strong enough to withstand the stresses of flight, and in this regard we are reliant on the designer of the model to produce a good quality design. For plan and kit built models, the strength of the glued joints is up to us. We need to select the right type of adhesive and use it properly.

 


RC model airplane fuselage

4. Check that all visible joints are properly glued. This ARF model was very well built.

Check that all visible joints are properly glued. This ARF model was very well built.


5. The structure of a model must be sound. Here, the spar has been cut to clear the ribs - this was an airborne disaster waiting to happen. Oddly, the rest of the model's woodwork was quite sound.

The structure of a model must be sound. Here, the spar has been cut to clear the ribs - this was a disaster waiting to happen.

 

Airframe Strength and Integrity
In the case of ARF (ARTF) models we are reliant on the manufacturer to build the airframe with sufficient strength. Things are much better than they were a few years ago, but it’s still not unknown for glue joints to be poorly made. For this reason, it’s always worth inspecting an airframe carefully to look for any joints that are inadequately glued. Thin or medium CA glue can be added to any joints that are suspect. Check also for broken components and repair these.

Since ARF models are supplied covered, not all areas will be accessible for inspection. However, it should be possible to inspect much of the fuselage interior, and at least some parts of the wings. Particular areas to check are the landing gear attachment and motor mounts. Again, things are better than they used to be but in my experience, these areas can still be weak points for some otherwise good models.

Used models should be treated with particular caution. One beautiful scale electric model I purchased some years ago had the wing spar cut away near the root area in order to clear the ribs! This disaster in waiting was only discovered because I removed the model's covering to inspect the structure after developing a suspicion about its integrity. The seller claimed the model had been flown, but if it had, he's certainly not pulled much in the way of G-forces. Fortunately, the rest of the model had been built to a good airworthy standard.

 


EDF RC model

6. The model must balance at a safe position. If the CG is outside safe limits, the model will be difficult or impossible to fly. This EDF model is constructed from foam and is the work of Dave Chinery.

The model must balance at a safe position. If the CG is outside safe limits, the model will be difficult or impossible to fly.


RC model airplane landing gear

7. Pay particular attention to the strength of highly stressed areas such as the landing gear.

Pay particular attention to the strength of highly stressed areas such as the landing gear.


Washout on aircraft wing

8. The presence of washout can be detected by comparing the incidence of the wing tip and root. The tip of this business jet is set at a lower angle than the wing tip.

The presence of washout can be detected by comparing the incidence of the wing tip and root. The tip of this business jet is set at a lower angle than the wing tip.


RC model aircraft hardware

9. All hardware must be fit for purpose. Replace any items which are not of good quality.

All hardware must be fit for purpose. Replace any items which are not of good quality.

 

Straight and True
As well as being strong, a model's structure also needs to be built true to fly well. A model with a banana-shaped fuselage will never fly very well. Warps in flying surfaces will also spoil a model's flying qualities. the only exception to this is the use of 'washout' which is the deliberate and precise inclusion of a small amount of warp such that the tip of a wing has a lower angle of attack than the root. It is essential that both wings have the same amount of washout. Washout will promote safe stalling behaviour, as it encourages the wing root to stall before the wing tip, meaning that the model is much less likely to drop a wing and enter a roll as a result of stalling.

The opposite of washout, wash-in, where the wing tips have a higher angle of attack than the wing root is dangerous and must be avoided at all costs.

Balance Matters
A model must of course be balanced at the recommended position. Often components can be moved within a model to obtain the correct balance point, but if not, weight will have to be added, usually to the nose. Don't be afraid of adding a little weight to achieve the correct balance. A heavy model may not fly so well, but a model with an out of limits CG won't fly for long!

The lateral (side to side) balance of a model should also be checked. Any imbalance can be corrected with a little weight added to one wing tip.

Click here to read part 2

Get more articles like this one absolutely free with every
Gibbs Guides e-magazine. Join the mailing list!

 

<<<  Back Top